• Home
  • Projects
  • Writing
    • Matt 6:24
    • Kitchen Sink
    • The Privilege Is All Mine
    • Other
  • Uptown Music Lessons
  • About
Gio Andollo

Christians, please check your privilege at the stable door.

12/24/2013

1 Comment

 
'Tis the day before Christmas 
and all through the nation,
privileged Christians are certain
there's a war on their celebration.

Hehe. I just whipped that up...

That's right, it's Christmas Eve and the holly-jolliness is nearly at its boiling point... At least for those of us who are secure enough in our private observation of these supposed holy days not to get offended by the words "Happy Holidays" or by the removal (or ever-so-slight obstruction) of nativity scenes in government buildings.
Picture
But I'm sorry to say that not everyone recognizes their Christian privilege. In fact many Christians still feel that they are under attack, fighting the defensive in what they call the War On Christmas. They somehow don't see (or care) that their religion is still the dominant religion of this country, that countless people who do not share their religious convictions must experience this "holiday season" for a month or two each year, through the ubiquitous music and imagery of Christmas. Instead, many Christians paint themselves as the victims, as the oppressed, when just the opposite is true.

Jon Stewart again addressed this matter a couple weeks ago...
First off: we all know that Christmas is everyone's favorite holiday. Everyone's. EVERYONE'S. Need I say more?

But the best part of this bit is where Jon Stewart points out just how nuts FOX News pundit Gretchen Carlson really is. In one clip, she asks, rhetorically, "why do I have to drive around with my kids to look for nativity scenes, and be like...'look, there's baby Jesus behind the festivus pole made of beer cans?' It's nuts!"

Indeed. First of all, why should there be nativity scenes at the state capitol building? Or even on the streets? If Gretchen wants to show her kids a nativity scene then she can always put one in her own home (mine always had one under the Christmas tree); or visit her local churches (mine always had one with live people, animals, and even baby Jesus... not to mention the epic Christmas pageant we held at the county auditorium each year, which told the full story of Jesus from birth to Ascension!); OR finally, as Jon so aptly points out, she can bring her kids to the very place where she works - the plaza outside the News Corp building, where FOX News had their very own live nativity scene.

But I suppose that she wouldn't then have grounds to play the victim card. 

Thankfully, Jon's War On Christmas coverage didn't end there. He then went on to discuss some comments that Megyn Kelly had made regarding Santa Claus.
PictureIllustration by Mark Stamaty
Before I address those comments myself, I just want to remind everyone that Santa Claus has nothing at all to do with the actual Christmas story; in my humble opinion, Christians ought to denounce Santa as both a distraction and a symbol of consumerism, capitalism, and greed (as Jon Stewart himself did earlier this month... perhaps Stewart understands the meaning of Christmas better than the FOX News pundits, who are supposedly defending it?) But it still gets the FOX News people in a huff if you attack Santa Claus, or apparently, the conventional ideas about who he is. So...

In an article on Slate.com, culture blogger Aisha Harris insisted that Santa Claus should no longer be a white man. Having struggled with the image of a white Santa across the US cultural spectrum but a Black Santa in her own home, she suggested that instead Santa should just be a cartoon penguin. And yes, she gave some very compelling and valid reasons, though obviously tongue-in-cheek. 

FOX News pundit Megyn Kelly took the piece a little too seriously and, perhaps trusting that none of her viewers would actually go and read the piece, shot back with, "Santa just is white." Kelly then misrepresented Harris' argument by saying, "this person is just arguing that maybe we should also have a black Santa." (In fact, Harris was saying - again - that Santa should be a penguin) I suppose Megyn just had an inkling that the very idea of a black Santa would enrage her audience as much as it had enraged her.

But this was a rather strange position to take, given that with relatively transparent vulnerability, Harris had first written "I remember feeling slightly ashamed that our black Santa wasn’t the 'real thing.'" I suppose Kelly is too blinded by her White privilege and victim mentality to possibly imagine how difficult it might be for a family of color to integrate a white-skinned Santa into their holiday traditions.

And never mind that Santa Claus is based on the historical figure of Saint Nicholas, who was actually from present-day Turkey and probably had brown skin, not white. In any case, he was certainly not Caucasian. But I'll let Jon Stewart make the case, because he's a lot funnier than I am (and has a bigger budget and more writers).

And don't even get me started on the idea that Jesus was white...

Look.

It's Christmas Eve. If you're a Christian reading this, then I suppose you're celebrating tonight and tomorrow the birth of Yeshua of Nazareth, who came as a baby to a lowly family and oppressed people; who as a grown man humbled himself as a servant; and whom we yet posthumously call the Prince of Peace and King of Kings. So how's about we lay down our rhetorical arms this Christmas, beat our swords into plowshares, love our neighbors (whether Christian or not, as Jesus directed us to do), and perhaps - God willing - we can even check our privilege at the stable door. Thus we might actually follow the example of Him whom we find in the manger. (See: Phillippians 2:1-8)

In that spirit, I wish you all a joyful and peaceful holiday season, whatever you may (or may not) be celebrating. Amen (and a-women too).
1 Comment

Solidarity with the Subaltern

12/2/2013

0 Comments

 
Last week I stumbled upon an article regarding the importance of intersectionality and subaltern voices in the discourse on privilege. It is written in response to British leftist writer Mark Fisher, who had recently published a piece for The North Star likening the subaltern and "neo-anarchist" communities to blood-sucking vampires. 

He's apparently exiting Dracula's castle.
Picture
By "neo-anarchist," Fisher refers to the likes of Occupy protesters. Which means he's talking about me. This is personal. But truth be told, I'm totally oblivious to the socio-political conditions in the UK that he is speaking to. So I will refrain from comment on his piece (nay, I've not even bothered to waste time reading it). Instead, I'd like to share excerpts from the article that I found in response. 

I've selected and edited the excerpts below (careful not to distort their meaning or message) to reflect a universality for the privilege discussion. The author, whose name I've not been able to find yet, could just as easily be speaking of the US, on behalf of subaltern voices here, or really anywhere. It's crucial that we who have privilege and power are able to incline our ears to such voices.
It’s pretty depressing that black women are still fighting to get white men [and women] to recognise how racism structures our lives. A battle for dominance is being played out on the terrain of identity by white male leftists stung by the explosion of new, subaltern perspectives emerging on social media platforms like twitter. What is being reconfigured here is the notion of democracy.

Today in this climate of mass-unemployment and social, political and economic upheaval, I can see that most of the ire directed at black feminist scholarship and theory in the UK is coming from white males on the left who fear losing their privilege. Perhaps that debate on intersectionality/privilege is too academic or alienating... but it is nevertheless an important one. Intersectionality is coalitional-building. It is a critical thinking tool that enables us all to analyse how race, gender, sexuality, disability, income, language, nationality and so on work together to shape our experiences. In short it helps to deconstruct difference and the Other.

[Some argue that] there are “petit-bourgeois” opinion-shapers who adopt the voice and language of the subaltern but whose privilege remains unexamined or unacknowledged. So full disclosure, I am - by Marx’s definition - working class. I identify as Black working class woman and yet I can’t accept that [white heterosexual male] media pundits speak for people like me who are “the working class”. I see only gate-keepers setting the parameters of what is acceptable speech and primarily seeking dominance. I have less invested in maintaining the status quo and less to lose by speaking out when I do.

We are always striving towards the truth of our situation. To get there involves discussion. Some of it uncomfortable because it shows up those nether regions we’d rather ignore. And it takes an act of courage, not malice, to point it out.
If you'd like to read the full piece, find it here.
0 Comments
    The privilege of a lifetime is being who you are.
    -Joseph Campbell

    Blog
    About
    Leverage
    ** disclaimers **

    Archives

    August 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    June 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012

    Categories

    All
    Anti-racism
    Black & White
    Blogging
    Childhood
    Christian
    Comedy
    Education
    Entertainment
    Ethnicity
    Feminism
    Harassment
    Hiphop
    International
    Language
    Leverage
    Lifestyle
    Male Privilege
    Marriage Equality
    Misogyny
    New Jim Crow
    News Media
    Occupy Wall Street
    Partriarchy
    Poverty
    Prejudice
    Privilege
    Racism
    Religion
    Sexism
    Solidarity
    Stereotypes
    Straight Privilege
    Usa Privilege
    Violence
    White Privilege

Home | Writing | GioSafari | Music Lessons | Calendar | Bio
Thanks for visiting! If you'd like to use/copy/distribute something, please e-mail :D
©2010-2013 Gio Andollo. All rights reserved.